Testing Validity of the Reasons and Criteria for Determining Revelation Order of the Qur’ān

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Assistant Professor of Ferdowsi University of Mashhad

Abstract

The present research is to identify the extent of validity of the criteria for determining revelation order of the Qur’ān and to analyze and criticize different views in this regards. Mentioning the Makki and Medanis traditions, the traditions of reasons of revelation, historical evidences and the infallibles' conducts, content analysis of the Qur'ānic verses, Imam Ali's Book, the traditions of revelation order, the originality and validity of thematic interpretation and Qur’ān revelation, reference to the verses of "the verses revealed first" and "the verses revealed in the end", and some other related concepts to them, the researcher has attempted to depict the extent of validity and comprehensiveness of each of these factors in historiography of the Qur’ān and determining the revelation order. The researcher believes that the determination revelation order and its seizure is more related to Imam Ali's Book and the traditions of revelation order compared to other factors assuming that other mentioned references and criteria are not worth referring to solely. Implementing a kind of critical evaluation of other indices, the researcher maintains that their efficiency would be in effect provided with the fact that they are merged and be compatible with traditions of revelation order. Moreover, this writing is of the view that by determining revelation order, approaching revelation order interpretation using thematic method could be one of the most fruitful and essential approaches that could be one of the results to be noted, thus the researcher has attempted to show the harmony of these two factors.

Keywords


  1. ‘Ᾱmeli, J. (1410 Lunar.). Haqāeq Hāmmah Howl Qur’an Al- Karim. Qom: Jameh Almodaressing Islamic Publishing Company.
  2. Ale Ghazi, A. M. (2003/1382). Bayānalm’āni ‘alā Hasbe Tartibanozool. Damascus: Maṯbaqah Attaraqi.
  3. Askari, M. (1408 Lunar). Ma'alimalmadresatayn. Tehran: Albe'thah Institute.
  4. Ayyashi, M. b. M. (1380 Lunar). Tafsire Ayyashi. Tehran: Maktabah 'Ilmiyah Alislamiyah Publishing Company.
  5. Ayāzi, M.A. (2009/1378). Kāvoshi dar Tarikhe Jam’e Qur’an. Rasht: Ketab-e Mobin Publications.
  6. Bahjatpour, A. (2011/1390). Hamgām bā wahy: Tafsir-e Tanzili. Qom: Tamhid Institute.
  7. Balāghi, M.J. (1420 Lunar). Ᾱlāorahman fi Tafsirelqorān. Qom: Be’sat Foundation.
  8. Bāzargān, M. (1995/1374). Pa be Paye Wahy. Tehran: Islamic Culture Publications Office.
  9. Darvazeh, M. (2002/1381). Attafisirelhadith. Dārol Ihya Al-kotob Al-‘Arabiyah. Eisa Albabi wa Shorka Publications.
  10. Darvazeh, M. (2005/1384). Siratorrasool Ṣowar Moqtabesah min Al-Qur’ān Al-karim. ‘Eisa Albabi wa Shorka Publications.
  11. Fārsi, J. (1983/1362). Payambari wa …. Vol. 3. Moasese Anjam Ketab Publishing Company.
  12. Habankeh Al-meidāni, A. H. (2000). Ma’ārij Attafakor wa Daqāiq Attadabor. Damascus: Dārolqalam. 1st Floor.
  13. Haskāni, O. (1411 Lunar.). Shawahidotanzil Liqawaidottafsil. Research by Mahmoudi, M. Tehran: Islamic Culture and Guidance Ministry Publications.
  14. Hojjati, M. (2005/1384). Asbābanozool. Tehran: Islamic Culture Publications Office. The 11th edition.
  15. Ibne Hanbal, A. (1391 Lunar). Almosnad. Explanation by Shakir, A.M. Cairo: Darolma’aref.
  16. Ibne Nadim, M. b. Ishaq. (1967/1346). Alfihrist. Tajaddod. R. (Trans.). Tehran: Bange Bazargani Publications.
  17. Ibne Qarnās. Ahsan alqiṣaṣ. (2010). Tarikhal Islam kamā worida minalmaṣdar ma’a Tartib Assor Hasabanozool. Beiroot: Aljamal.
  18. Ibne Sa’d, M. (1417 Lunar). Aṯabaqātol Kobrā. Research by Riadh. A. Beiroot: Dār Ihyā AttorāthAl’arabi.
  19. Ibne Shahr Ashoob, M.A. (n.d). Manqib Ale Abitalib. Research by Rasooli Mahallati, H. Qom: Allāmeh Publications.
  20. Jāberi, M.A. (2008). Fahm Al-qorānilkarim: Attafsir Al-wadhih hasb Tartibannozool. Beiroot: Derāsātolwahidah Al-‘arabiyah.
  21. Jalāli Nayeeni, M. (1986/1365). Tarikh-e Jam’e Qur’an-e Karim. Introduction by Mahdawi Dāmghāni, A. 1st edition. Noqreh Publication.
  22. Khouee, A. (1408 Lunar). Albayān Fi Tafsir Al-Qur’ān. Beiroot: Dārazahra.
  23. Koleyni, M. b. Y. (1388 Lunar). Alkāfi (Osul). Explanations by Alghefāri, A. Tehran: Manshoorat Almaktabah Al-islamiyah.
  24. Mahdavi Rād, (2003/1382). Āfāq Tafsir. Maqālāt wa Maqulāti dar Tafsir Pajoohi. Tehran: Hasti Nama Publications.
  25. Majlesi, M. (1403 Lunar). Bihārolanwar fi Dorar Ikhbār Aimah Al-Aṯhār. Beiroot: Dār Ihyah Attorāth Al'arabi.
  26. Ma'refat, M. (1417 Lunar). Attamhid fi Olum Al-Qur'an. Qom: Islamic Publishing Office.
  27. Ma'refat, M. (1425 Lunar). Attafsir walmofassiroon fi Thoubah Alqashib. Mashhad. Razawi University for Islamic Sciences.
  28. Mofid. M. b. M. b. Na'mān. (1413 Lunar). Muṣannifāt "Awaelol Maqālāt". Qom: Sheykh Mofid Commemoration Congress.
  29. Nekoonām,J. (2003/1382). Pajooheshi dar Muṣhaf Imam Ali (A). Rasht: Ketabe Mobin Publications.
  30. Rāmyār, M. (1983/1362). Tarikhe Qur’an. Tehran: Amir Kabir Publications.
  31. Rashid, R. M. (n.d) Tafsir Al-Qur’ān Al-karim (Al-minar). 2nd edition. Beiroot: Dārolfikr.
  32. Ṣadr, H. (1975/1354). Shi’a wa Payegozari Olum Eslami. Mokhtari, M. (Trans.) Tehran: Islamic Grand Library Publications.
  33. Ṣadr, M. (1400 Lunar). Almadresah Al-Qur’aniyah. Beiroot: Dār Atta’arof Al-ma’ṯboo’āt.
  34. Suyūṯi, J. (1984/1363). Alitqan fi Olumel Qur’an. Corrected by Ibrahim, M.A. Translated by Haeri Qazwini, M. Tehran: Amir Kabir Publications.
  35. Sezgin, F. (1412 Lunar). Tarikh Atorāthol ‘Arabi. Fahmi Hijazi, M. (Translation and Research). Qom: Ayatollah Mar’ashi Najafi Liberary.
  36. Shahrestani, M. b. Abdolkarim. (1989/1368). Mafatiholasrār wa Maṣābihol Abrar. Introduction by Haeri, A. Tehran: Markaze Nashre Nosakhe Khatti.
  37. Shakir, M. (n.d).Naqd wa Barrasi roykardhaye Mokhtalif Tafsir bar Asās Tartibe Nozool. Modhamatan Website.
  38. Sharafoddin, A. (1402 Lunar). Almorāji’āt. Research by Arrādhi, H. Beiroot: Jami’ah Al-Islamiyah.
  39. Sharif, R.M. (1412 Lunar). Nahjolbalagheh. Dhabte Ṣobhi Ṣaleh. Qom: Manshoorāt Dārolhijrah.
  40. Ṣobhi, Ṣ. (1972). Mabahith fi Olum Al-Qur’an. Beiroot: Dārolelm Lilmalayeen. The 7th edition.
  41. Ṯabāṯabāyee, M. (2006/1385). Qur’an dar Islam. The 11th edition. Qom: Daftare Entesharat-e Eslami Jameh Modaresin Hozah ‘Ilmiyah.
  42. Ṯabāṯabāyee, M. (2015/1394). Almizān fi Tafsir Al-Qurān. Beiroot: Manshoorāt Moaseseh Al’alami Lilmaṯboo’āt.
  43. Ṯabrasi, F. b. H. (2000). Majmaolbayan fi Tafsirel Qur’an. Beiroot: Dār Ihya Attorāth Al’arabi.
  44. Ya'qubi, A. b. Abi Y. (1995/1374). Tarikhe Ya'qubi. Ayati.M. (Tr.). The 7th edition. Tehran: Elmi Farhangi Publishing Company.
  45. Zarkashi, B. (2001). Alborhān fi Olumelqor’an. Beiroot: Dārolfikr.